Click here to enter my other blog: Jane Austen's World.
Showing posts with label Colleen McCullough. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colleen McCullough. Show all posts

Monday, October 17

Death Comes to Pemberley, P.D.James's contribution to Jane Austen sequels

Death Comes to Pemberley by P.D. James will be available in the UK on November 3rd and in December in the U.S.

The author told The Associated Press during a telephone interview that the new book allows her to indulge two great passions: Austen and crime stories.
‘It has been a joy to revisit Pride and Prejudice and to discover, as one always does, new delights and fresh insights. I have to apologise to Jane Austen for involving her beloved Elizabeth in a murder investigation but this fusion of my two enthusiasms – for the novels of Jane Austen and for writing detective stories – has given me great pleasure which I hope will be shared by my readers.’
The plot starts out dramatically. Six years after Darcy and Elizabeth are married, they are still happy and have two sons. But then their lives are changed when Lydia Wickahm arrives in a careening wagon in the middle of the night shouting that her husband has been murdered.And so the mystery begins.

This book and the impending publication of a modern reworking of Sense and Sensibility by Joanna Trollope indicates how popular Jane Austen and her novels still are.  That best-selling novelists are jumping on the Jane Austen sequel bandwagon indicates that there is still plenty of money to be made. Let's hope that both P.D.James and Joanna Trollope come up with better Jane Austen inspired novels than Colleen McCullough, whose excruciating  The Independence of Miss Mary Bennet wasn't worth the $1.00 I had to fork over to a used book store.

Sunday, September 26

Jane Austen Rip Off Throwdown

I finally read Colleen McCullough's The Independence of Miss Mary Bennet, which came out several years ago. Here's my review, which is based on the one I placed on Goodreads:

Imagine an author, Colleen McCullough, whose bestsellers like The Thornbirds, have made her rich and famous. Imagine another author, Jane Austen, whose novels did not make her rich and who became famous only decades after her death. The second author inspires a booming industry 200 years later that makes a profit for publishers who have been busily spinning off sequels and prequels and mashups, and for producers of films, plays and musicals.


The impulse that made Colleen McCullough jump on the Jane Austen bandwagon should have remained inside of her. This novel purports to be about Mary Bennet, the least pretty or interesting of the Bennet sisters. McCullough's book places Darcy's and Elizabeth's marriage in jeopardy, turns Jane Bingley into a breeding sow and Elizabeth into a boring person. Lydia is a whorish wife who sleeps around, Kitty is insufferable, and Darcy's son and heir is unable to stand up to his harsh father.  All traces of Mary's pedantic personality have disappeared, and she has actually become quite pretty (how this was accomplished I can't remember, but it had something to do with an operation on her pocky skin). After Mrs. Bennet's death, Mary throws off the mantle of wimpish responsibility and becomes an independent spirit desired by men.


Darcy, who in Pride and Prejudice doted on his sister Georgianna, is hugely disappointed with Elizabeth's performance as a breed cow, for she had the bad grace to deliver three daughters before his son and heir was born. McCullough's Darcy lacks any resemblance to the caring, responsible  man worshiped by his doting housekeeper, Mrs. Reynolds, and beloved by Elizabeth Bennet and his good friend Charles Bingley.


Devoid of Jane Austen's colorful characters or wit, the plot of this odd novel plods along  a tired, predictable and formulaic road. I hated wasting my precious life on this book, but had to see if it would get better. It did not. 


Look, had this book been another Colleen McCullough original, without the association to Pride and Prejudice, it would have stood on its own merit. But, with its pretend relationship to Jane Austen's characters, it is a colossal rip off, monetarily speaking. Potential readers who purchase this book will assume that the characters continue where Jane's left off, and that they will have retained a smidgen of their original personalities. Nope. McCullough totally ignores the future Jane had mapped out for the Darcys, Bingleys, and Bennets, and took them into her own brooding Thornbirdy territory. 

I don't need happily ever afters in my books. Still, the cynicism that went behind this production is breathtaking - the publisher and McCullough must have raked in a great deal of cash before the public realized that this product was meant to be a cash rip off, not an homage to Jane.


Today's question is this: If you have read the book do you agree with my assessment? If you have not read the book, are you inspired to read it (just to see what I'm fussing about?) or will you keep on ignoring it?


For those who are now anxious to read The Independence of Miss Mary Bennet, Alibris offers a hardback copy for $.99. I know that's a steep price, but I couldn't find a free copy.

The Independence of Mary Bennet
I read it and hated it
I read it and didn't finish it
I read it and ... gee, I forgot the plot
I read it and liked it
I loved it. Get over yourself.
I didn't read it, but want to read it now.
I didn't read it, but $.99 is too much to spend
I didn't read it and never will. Thanks for saving me the trouble.


  
pollcode.com free polls